Does Kirsty Williams regret joining Carwyn's cabinet?

If you were to ask what was one of the major exports from Wales, Teachers may not come to mind, but English literature and other media often have a Welsh character as part of the staff of an English school.

There's a possible PHD for  someone  in this.

Arguably It reflects  a more diverse education system in which working and lower middle class pupils had more access to the old Grammar Schools where  Ceredigion provided unprecedented 50% of places in Grammar school.

Unfortunately  it meant we lost some of our Brightest and Best who should have been here building a Nation.

Now we find that  Applications for teacher training places in Wales  have dropped by a quarter in the past year, new figures have showed.

According to the BBC
 

There were 740 applicants from Wales by mid December 2017, according to data published by the education service UCAS.
That compares with 1,000 applicants at the same time in 2016, and 1,010 in 2015.
The Welsh Government said it was early in the application cycle so the figures should be viewed with caution.
The 26% fall since last year comes despite new financial incentives for aspiring teachers.

Experts cite the perceived workload of teachers and lower financial incentives for teacher training in Wales compared with England as potential barriers to attracting applicants.
Aspiring teachers need to obtain a grade B, or above, in their GCSEs in English and maths, as well as two A-levels, before they can start their training programme.
Those planning to teach pupils aged three to 11 (early years and primary) must also have achieved a grade C, or above, in a GCSE science subject.

Hayden Llewellyn, chief executive of the Education Workforce Council (EWC), the independent regulator in Wales for teachers, said data from the Higher Education Funding Council (HEFCW) also showed teacher training institutions had struggled to recruit to Welsh Government targets over the last three years. 

"This under-recruitment mainly relates to certain secondary subjects such as mathematics, English, the sciences, modern foreign languages and Welsh.
"Clearly graduates in such subjects are in demand and may choose not to train as teachers," he said in a statement.

Rebecca Williams from the Welsh teaching union UCAC said she thought there were a number of issues behind the fall in applications.

"One of them is teacher workload - and the perception of workload on teachers," she said.
"By now, I think salaries are part of the problem as well, because of the freeze on public sector salaries."

The pay scale for newly qualified teachers in Wales is from £22,917 to £33,824 a year.

In October the government announced that graduates with a 1st class degree or a PhD or masters degree undertaking a postgraduate teaching degree in maths, Welsh, computer science, physics and chemistry would receive a £20,000 incentive. 

Modern language students would receive a £15,000 incentive.

A Welsh Government spokesman said:

"We want Wales to be attractive for students training to be teachers.
"At the end of last year, we announced new and improved incentives to teach priority subjects such as physics, chemistry, computer science, maths, Welsh and modern foreign languages.
"We are also reforming the way in which initial teacher education is delivered, putting in place new accreditation criteria and strengthening the ways in which schools and universities work together."

It must be very frustrating for  Education Secretary Kirsty Williams who said 

"In Wales we experience challenges in recruiting to certain subjects and in certain geographical locations. This is the challenge we must, and will, rise to,"

Ms Williams the sole Lib Dem in the assembly  former La Pasionaria of the  opposition benches is now part of the (Not a Coalition) Welsh Labour Government.

I suspect that  she would have  much more to say if she hadn't taken up a government  position.

It is perhaps Carwyn Jones's cleverest stroke in that he has silenced one of the most effective voices  on the opposition benches by offering Ms Williams the Eduction remit.

But I wonder if her party are regretting this  as they continue to languish in the polls and they hardly seem to exit in Wales?